Skip to content

Design review, datapath cards (control-path pass) — 2026-09-21

Second pass after mechanical-2026-09-21.md (mechanical). Cards: ALU v3.2, Index Register 1.1, Memory v1.3, Mem Switch 1.1, Mem Register 1.0. Method: every select / enable / strobe / clock / reset net was traced pin-to-pin from kicad/<ver>/reports/netlist.net (pin names and types from the Eagle symbols) with chip types from the Eagle .brd, and checked against the way the sequencer microcode actually drives the bus (firmware/microcode/ucode-generator2/), because several hardware choices only work under a microcode convention. Signal polarity: - prefix = active low. Gate delays quoted are LS-TTL typicals from the datasheets in docs/datasheets/.

Severity: HIGH = would stop the card working or damage parts; MED = unreliable / depends on a convention that is not enforced by hardware; LOW = housekeeping or documentation.

The cards' findings are in each card's own reviews/ folder:

Card Findings File
Memory v1.3 M1-M8 hardware/cards/memory/reviews/v1.3-datapath-2026-09-21.md
Index Register 1.1 R1-R3 hardware/cards/register/reviews/v1.1-datapath-2026-09-21.md
ALU v3.2 A1-A3 hardware/cards/alu/reviews/v3.2-datapath-2026-09-21.md
Mem Switch 1.1 and Mem Register 1.0 (one section) B1-B2 hardware/cards/mem-switch/reviews/v1.1-datapath-2026-09-21.md
Mem Register 1.0 (points to the Mem Switch file) hardware/cards/mem-register/reviews/v1.0-datapath-2026-09-21.md

This page keeps the parts that belong to no single card: the system-level items S1-S3 and the summary.


System-level items found while tracing (not on the five cards, recorded so they are not lost)

S1 — MED: no power-on reset anywhere; -RESET is a manual RS latch

Sequencer-logic v2.1: RESET = IC32.4 (74ALS02) = NOR(FP-RESET [switch RESET0 via R7], RUN); RUN = IC32.1 = NOR(RESET, FP-EXECUTE); -RESET = IC36.6 (74LS04) = NOT RESET. There is no RC or supervisor. At power-up the latch settles arbitrarily, so until the button is pressed the memory card's FORCE-ROM (IC12A PRE), all sixteen 74LS192 register counters (CLR = RESET), and the ALU carry/shift flip-flops (IC9 CLR) are undefined. Bench: meter on C30 after a cold power-up, before touching the front panel.

S2 — LOW: reset polarity is consistent across cards

Bus -RESET (active low, totem-pole from IC36.6): memory IC12A PRE (active low), ALU IC9 CLR (active low), register IC34 XNOR(GND, -RESET) -> active-high CLR of the 192s. No mismatch.

S3 — LOW: control-line idle state is "floating" bus-wide

See M5. Every control line on rows B/C is a 374 output with OC = -BUS-EN; no card and not the backplane pulls them. The memory card is the one that could lose data from it (M2, M5).


Summary

ID Card Sev One line
M1 Memory HIGH (masked) FORCE-ROM clock = ADDR15 AND VMA races the register card's address drivers; clears on the first cycle whenever the address bus floats. Hidden today by the microcode holding -VMA in every line, which also disables all -VMA gating of the chip selects.
M2 Memory MED 28C64 -WE = -MEM-WR, unprotected; during FORCE-ROM every address selects the ROM block, so a boot-time store writes the EEPROM. Shipped monitor avoids it (BR first).
M3 Memory MED TMP registers latch on the leading edge of -TMP-REG-LDn; depends on the microcode's source-one-line-early convention; moveRegtoTmp breaks it (unused).
M4/B1 Memory + bring-up MED (config) Low RAM ($0000-$7FFF) cannot be jumpered out; with a bring-up card fitted (or FORCE-ROM after reset) two or three drivers on DATA0-7 at $0000.
R1 Register MED CD4077 CMOS thresholds (VIH 3.5 V) on LS-driven -RESET, -RDSEL, -LDSEL, -HL-SWAP; ~100 ns in the 245 enable/direction path.
R2 Register MED UP/DN = OR(select, -REG-UP): deselecting while -REG-UP is low counts the deselected register; safe only under the microcode ordering the author flagged.
S1 Sequencer MED No power-on reset; FORCE-ROM, registers, carry undefined until the button.
A1 ALU LOW/MED BR-COND floats when JP1 = -ALU-FUNC and -ALU-FUNC is high.
M5/S3 Memory LOW All bus control inputs float (374 OC = -BUS-EN) before READY / on handover; no pull-ups anywhere.
M6, M7, M8, R3, A2, A3, B2 various LOW Open LS04 inputs; JP1 must be fitted; RN5/RN6 value unknown; no same-card swap; -AC-LD-INV also flips BR-COND; ns-scale internal overlaps; 244 vs 240 documentation.

Checked and clean: memory write-strobe ordering and 62256 -OE/-WE relation, block-jumper decode, FORCE-ROM uses raw ADDR15; register-card bus direction (the 1.2 open question is answered: correct as drawn), swap path exclusivity, load timing, address drive, 192 cascade; ALU accumulator/carry/borrow/carry-in logic, comparator cascade seeding, shift register and shift-out, 4078 output polarity, transceiver enables; bring-up cards' read/write qualification and decode.

Last updated 26 October 2026